Blade of Steel has no direct affiliation to the NHL or NHLPA

Jordan Binnington admits struggles as Joel Hofer outshines him in St. Louis


PUBLICATION
Cimon Asselin
April 15, 2026  (10:28)
SHARE THIS STORY

St. Louis Blues goaltender Jordan Binnington (50) defends the net during the third period against the Pittsburgh Penguins at Enterprise Center.
Photo credit: Connor Hamilton-Imagn Images

Jordan Binnington got the win Tuesday night, but the St. Louis Blues goalie isn't pretending everything is fine.

His words this morning were unusually candid for a goaltender still getting paychecks.
"For me, looking in the mirror after this year, I've got to elevate my process," Binnington said. "I want to be better and I have the will to be better."
That's not the kind of quote you usually get from a starter mid-April. That's a guy who knows what the numbers look like.
He stopped 18 of 23 shots in a 7-5 win over Pittsburgh on Tuesday. The offense bailed him out. It won't always do that.
Over 40 starts this season, Binnington has a .873 save percentage and just one shutout. That's a bottom-tier number for a goaltender carrying a $6 million cap hit.

Joel Hofer's season makes Binnington's situation harder to ignore

Meanwhile, backup Joel Hofer has gone 20-13 in 45 starts with a .909 save percentage and six shutouts. In the same building. On the same team.
That's not a slight on Binnington. That's just a brutal side-by-side comparison that lives in Doug Armstrong's spreadsheets right now.
The Blues are 36-33-12, ranked 24th overall with a goal differential of -29. They've won three straight and gone 6-3-1 in their last 10, but that's a December rescue attempt dressed up as April momentum.
Binnington's quote about looking in the mirror landed differently because of that context. It's one thing for a .920 starter to say he wants to improve. It's another when the backup has outperformed you by 34 save percentage points all season.
Coach Jim Montgomery has a decision to think about heading into Thursday's road game at Utah. With the Blues already on the outside looking in on the Central Division, there's no pressure to protect feelings at this point in the year.
A $6 million goaltender with a .873 save percentage asking to be judged by a higher standard is either the most honest thing a struggling starter has said all season, or it's the kind of statement that only amplifies the pressure ahead of a contract conversation this summer.
Maybe both. This one isn't wrapped up yet.
POLL
5 HOURS AGO|23 ANSWERS
Jordan Binnington admits struggles as Joel Hofer outshines him in St. Louis

Should the Blues make Joel Hofer their undisputed starter next season?


BLADE OF STEEL
COPYRIGHT @2026 - ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
TERMS OF SERVICE - PRIVACY POLICY - COOKIE POLICY
RSS FEED - SITEMAP - ROBOTS.TXT